Skip page header and navigation

Provider trends: Pulse report suggests higher bill rates ahead

CWS 3.0 - Contingent Workforce Strategies

Provider trends: Pulse report suggests higher bill rates ahead

Katherine Alvarez
| December 10, 2024
SIA Pulse Report

main content

Staffing suppliers are integral to your ability to supply your organization with the appropriate contingent workers, making it imperative to stay informed about the market conditions, challenges and opportunities these partners face.

For example, providers participating in SIA’s recent Staffing Industry Pulse Survey expressed optimism about bill rates and orders, indicating increased use of contingent workers and more competition for talent among enterprise buyers.

“This report helps to inform contingent workforce buyers,” says Matt Norton, SIA’s workforce solutions research director. “Understanding the opportunities and the challenges that your staffing partners have allows you to be a more educated buyer and better partner. This not only benefits your program and your organization but also benefits the staffing partner and contingent workers. The results offer some positive indicators that the start of 2025 will be slightly better for staffing firms than a sluggish 2024, with orders and bill rates projected to pick up over the next six months.”

Here’s a look at some trends found within the report.

Provider Landscape

Bill rates. A net -1% of staffing firms reported an increasing trend in bill rates over the last three months, down from 1% in the September 2024 Update report, which reflected US staffing trends in August. However, the net percentage of staffing firms expecting an increasing trend in the next six months rose to 16% in the survey for the November report from 13% in September.

Published every other month, SIA’s US Staffing Industry Pulse Survey Report provides contingent workforce program managers with insight into the supplier’s environment and how it affects their organizations. This article covers results from the November 2024 Update report, which is based on a survey of 173 participating staffing firms and reflects US staffing trends in October.

Spend on temp labor. Overall, spending on temporary workers through US staffing firms fell by a median 5% year over year in October among staffing firms taking part in the Pulse survey, an improvement from the 8% decline recorded in the previous Pulse report covering August.

The travel nursing segment continued to post the largest median year-over-year decline in spend through staffing firms, down 21%. On the flip side, the largest increase was in locum tenens, which rose 3%.

Except for year-over-year declines of 3% in spend on industrial workers and 1% in IT staffing, the other seven segments were flat.

Labor market balance. Average sales difficulty increased to 3.67 in October from 3.52 in August (on a scale of 1 to 5). Although buyers may find staffing provers more flexible or willing to make exceptions they previously would not have, this is not a time for buyers to take advantage of these providers.

“Buyers want their providers to be financially strong and stable during good times and also during these more challenging market conditions,” says Dawn McCartney, SIA’s senior VP CWS Council.

Meanwhile, average recruiting difficulty at 3.08 in October was also up from 3.01 in the previous survey. Recruiting difficulty minus sales difficulty remains negative, indicating a loose labor market after a period in which it was historically tight.

New orders. The survey found new orders increased a net 23% in the last three months, up slightly from an increase of 22% reported in the survey for the September report. And staffing firms expect the market to heat up further, with a net 65% of staffing firms in November’s survey reporting they expect an increasing trend in the next six months, up from 59% in the previous survey.

Tactics to Increase Revenue/Profitability

The survey for the November Pulse report also asked participating staffing firms, “What tactics are you currently using to either increase revenue or increase profitability?”

Of the 89 firms that responded, 29% reported increasing sales, sales staff or marketing efforts. In addition, 12% mentioned expanding services/geographies.

The survey for SIA’s most recent Pulse Report included responses from 173 staffing firms that conduct business in the US. CWS Council members can download selected highlights of the US Staffing Industry Pulse Survey Report: November 2024 Selected Highlights.